On second thought

June 22, 2010 at 6:46 pm | Posted in Uncategorized | 5 Comments

Thanks to all who replied to my last post.  It was several months coming, and more of a last straw than a rational evaluation of the situation in which I find myself.  The problem is more my dislike of spine and the realization of just how big a part of neurosurgery it is, than anything else.  When you’re a student, you get to pick and choose (to some extent) the kinds of patients you follow and the kinds of surgeries you see.  And prior to this year, I was privileged to rotate only at large programs, where the faculty were highly specialized and could limit their practices.  As a result, I was able to avoid spine almost entirely.  And even when I couldn’t, I managed to scrub only with the cool people.

But it’s easily 60-70% of what you do. And it’s what pays the bills. So I think you have to like spine, at least on some level, in order to be a neurosurgeon.

And mostly I’ve just realized how miserable my life would be if I had to do that much spine in my practice.  In addition to dealing every day with the kind of personalities that neurosurgery seems to attract.

It’s been very difficult to sort out all the pieces of this puzzle–to figure out which of the things I dislike are situational and which are fundamental to the field.   To understand why I’ve enjoyed neurosurgery everywhere else I’ve been, but not here.  Put simply, I was sheltered elsewhere, and here I’m not.  Also, the omnipresent death and devastation does get to you after a while.  Even with a tolerance for disaster as high as mine.

It’s been a useful experience, though, and the skills and knowledge I’ve gained will likely serve me well in the future.  So no regrets.

5 Comments »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. So what would be a reasonable transition? I assume you’re gonna wanna keep cutting fuckers open, right? And not just start prescribing lipitor to fat dudes, right?

    • Definitely surgical. Or at the very least, procedural.

  2. Well, I wish you luck with your decision.

    I will tell you that while spine may be 60-70% of what you do as a resident, and it might even be 80-90% of what you do if you go into a traditional private practice, there are many ways to tailor your practice after residency to do very little spine. You could do an endovascular fellowship and be a cerebrovascular/endovascular neurosurgeon and never touch a spine patient. You could focus almost exclusively on brain tumors. You could do functional. You don’t even have to practice at a large academic medical center to do these things. Any large group of neurosurgeons will need these specialists, academic or not.

    I’m an endovascular neurosurgeon, and while I still do spine, I only do the types of spine cases I enjoy… degenerative cervical spine disease (radiculopathy, myelopathy) and straight forward lumbar disc herniations and lumbar stenosis. While I know how to do a lumbar fusion with pedicle screw fixation etc… I choose not to. I dislike those cases. So I send those patients to one of my partners.

    The personalities are hit or miss. I like the neurosurgeons I work with. None have severe pathos.

    My opinion is that much of this is situational in your case. Also, most start very interested in the brain side of neurosurgery, and most residents end up with a good appreciation for spine at some point during their residency. It is kinda like anything else, when you do something enough, and you get very good at it, you naturally start to like it. And with spine, you don’t usually have to worry about the devastation.

  3. A good friend of mine is a craniofacial surgeon, and he loves that shit. He does some cosmetic stuff to make extra money, and also does reconstructive surgery for poor fucks who really fucked themselves up–lots of motorcycle accidents.

  4. I will tell you that while spine may be 60-70% of what you do as a resident, and it might even be 80-90% of what you do if you go into a traditional private practice, there are many ways to tailor your practice after residency to do very little spine. You could do an endovascular fellowship and be a cerebrovascular/endovascular neurosurgeon and never touch a spine patient. You could focus almost exclusively on brain tumors. You could do functional. You don’t even have to practice at a large academic medical center to do these things. Any large group of neurosurgeons will need these specialists, academic or not.
    +1


Leave a comment

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.
Entries and comments feeds.